Architectural Shingles Vs 3 Tab Shingles
Architectural shingles are thicker asphalt shingle types that can create the appearance of visually stunning natural roofing like slate, cedar, or clay tiles at a fraction of the cost. Because of their extra thickness and contouring, they cost more than traditional asphalt shingles, but they last longer from 30 to 50 years and carry longer warranties. They are fire resistant, wind resistant, and prevent algae and mold growth making them one of the most popular type of roof shingles.
Talk to Contractors
Are Asphalt Shingles Good For Cold Climates
Yes, asphalt shingle roofs are known to be a relatively inexpensive roofing option that can survive cold winters. However, you should be aware that asphalt shingles wear down over time and require frequent replacing. In heavy winds and blizzards, these shingles could also be at risk of blowing off your roof.
Owens Corning Supreme: Basic 3
OC Supreme shingle is the most basic 3-tab shingle product from Owens Corning. You can often find this product on sheds, as well as double-decker and triple-decker rental properties, or properties being flipped.
Even higher-end single-family homes with a simple gable-style roof can sometimes be seen covered with the basic 3-tab shingles like Owens Corning Supreme.
Other manufacturers such as GAF and CertainTeed also have similar 3-tab 25 year shingles, as well as 30-year dimensional more premium shingle types.
One major downside of a 3-tab shingle is that its only rated for up to 60 MPH wind uplift, meaning that if a stronger storm were to occur near in your area, it could potentially lift up and take away your roof and sprinkle the pieces of shingles around the neighborhood! This is one key reason why you should not install this type of basic shingles, if you happen to live in a coastal area subjected to strong winds and/or a hurricane-prone area.
Performance: 60 MPH wind uplift rating, 10 year limited algae resistance, 25-year limited warranty
Cost: $25.00 to $29.00 per bundle, three bundles per square
Also Check: How Often To Get Shingles Booster
Factors That Affect Roof Shingles Cost
When you receive a roof shingle estimate from a professional, you can expect it to be made up of the roofing labor cost per square foot, the shingle materials needed for your roofing job, the removal and disposal of the existing roof, and the roofs characteristics. It is important to note all these factors when approximating how much it will cost to replace your roofs shingles.
Cost Of Shingles At Home Depot Vs Roofing Supplier
If you are planning to install the shingles yourself, you may be wondering whether you can save money by buying them at Home Depot rather than a roofing supply store.
In short: Home Depot roofing shingles will be only slightly cheaper a difference of about 2.5%
Here is an example of pricing I got from Beacon Sales in West Bridgewater, MA , for CertainTeed Landmark, GAF Timberline and IKO Cambridge laminated shingles.
This chart compares the cost of asphalt shingles from Beacon vs. Home Depot
|N/A||$25.00 / bundle or $75 / square|
Note, that prices for 3 tabs are calculated based on a quantity larger than 16 squares. The cost for architectural varieties is calculated based on a quantity larger than 12 squares.
Also Check: Does Shingles Shot Help With Genital Herpes
Gaf Royal Sovereign 3
GAF has been in the industry since 1888, releasing over 50 lines from commercial and residential roofing. Its Royal Sovereign asphalt line is the companys 3-tab shingle offering.
These Lowes roofing shingles come with GAFs signature Advanced Protection, meaning theyre the optimal combination of weatherizing, performance, and weight.
Theyre algae resistant, thanks to the manufacturers StainGuard Protection.
Did you know? Since 3-tab shingles have a fiberglass core, they contain less asphalt, making them more environmentally friendly.
Heavy rain, hail, and high winds are the number one enemy of any lightweight 3-tab roofing shingles at Lowes. But the Royal Sovereign line earns a Class F rating, withstanding winds of up to 100 miles per hour.
Most homeowners can recognize a standard 3-tab shingle by its simple design, yet this GAF line stands out from other strip roofing shingles at Lowes. The manufacturer has developed the Color Lock Ceramic Firing and uses granules to maintain the roofing shingles vibrant color profile.
Although available in seven colors, the black, brown, and slate shades are the most in-demand roofing shingle options at Lowes.
On average, Royal Sovereign shingles cost between $85 and $105 per square.
Check out our in depth comparative guide to GAF vs CertainTeed Shingles.
Owens Corning Trudefinition Duration Shingles
There is another popular asphalt roofing shingle at Lowes the TruDefinition Duration shingle. This line of architectural shingles is one of the most appealing and strongest on the market.
These Lowes roofing shingles are available in multiple colors, including:
Depending on which Lowes location you visit, some roofing shingle colors may be unavailable.
Compared to standard Oakridge shingles, the TruDefinition range features a color formula that captures bright and bold hues.
For instance, Harbor Blue bundles look good on most homes, while the Estate Gray option highlights the stylishness of larger houses.
Another notable difference is the companys patented SureNail Technology, which allows the shingle to fare well in extreme climates.
The TruDefinition roofing shingles at Lowes has a fabric strip built into the nailing area to bolster its gripping power. Furthermore, the SureNail technology provides a protective triple layer that covers the common bond area and prevents nail pull.
These features result in a wind rating of 130 miles per hour.
Did you know? Roofing material is tested at different wind speeds to determine its classification. Class D shingles withstand winds up to 90 miles per hour, while class G products have a threshold of 120 miles per hour. Class H materials resist uplift at winds up to 150 miles per hour.
Owens Corning backs Lowes TruDefinition roofing shingles with a limited lifetime warranty, which includes a TruProtection coverage of 10 years.
You May Like: Can You Put Calamine Lotion On Shingles
Type Of Roof Shingles Available At Lowes
- Architectural roofing shingles provide stunning three-dimensional appearance. Some of the most attractive architectural roofing shingles simulate cedar wood shakes. The products’ random colors and textures better accent steep roof planes, turrets, and gables features of roofs.
- Hip & Ridge
- This shingles are use to cover the Hip and Ridge portions of the roof. See Picture Below.
- Starter Shingles are installed in a row at the bottom of the roof. These shingles are instrumental in making sure that the asphalt shingles are correctly laid out on your roof. If these first starter shingles are not installed correctly, then there will be problems with the entire set of shingles. This starter course protects the roof by filling in any gaps that might happen in the event of wind and ice. See Picture Below.
- Also refer to as 3-Tab Shingles, have only 1 shingle tab size and shape. Cost less than architectural shingles. Are still preferred among residential rental properties and lower value homes where the initial higher cost can not be met for architectural shingles.
Owens Corning Oakridge: Laminated Architectural 30 Year Shingles
The 30-year, laminated architectural shingles are a step over the less-costly 3-tab shingles. OC Oakridge shingles are rated for up to 110 MPH wind uplift with 4 nails per shingle, or 130 MPH wind uplift with 6 nails per shingle. In other words, this product can be used in hurricane-prone areas.
Performance: 110 MPH wind uplift rating , 130 MPH wind uplift rating 10 year limited StreakGuard algae resistance, Limited lifetime material warranty
Cost: $30.00 to $35.00 per bundle, three bundles per 100 square feet
Read Also: Where Can I Get The New Shingles Vaccine
Certainteed Landmark Roofing Shingles
CertainTeed was founded in 1904 and has since become one of the leading manufacturers of asphalt shingles in the U.S.
Lowes most popular Certainteed roofing shingles are from the Landmark range.
Compared to other manufacturers, CertainTeeds production process yields more asphalt per roofing shingle.
Does this increase in volume mean the Landmark shingles outperform the competition? As a rule of thumb, heavier shingles have a longer lifespan and perform consistently in extreme weather conditions.
The CertainTeed Landmark range at Lowes has some of the heaviest roofing shingles on the market.
A clear nailing zone direction ensures a successful installation, and this product offers just that.
Another benefit of the Certainteed roofing shingles at Lowes is the companys StreakFighter technology which deters algae formation. The shingles copper-infused granules have natural algae-repellant properties and help the roof maintain its beauty and functionality.
Thanks to the dual-layer design, these shingles mimic the appearance of authentic wood shakes.
These roofing shingles are available in a wide range of color options at Lowes, which is why many homeowners choose them as their roofing solution.
However, Landmark shingles do have some drawbacks.
Customers have reported that this range has a shorter lifespan than expected, but thats probably due to improper installation.
See costs in your areaStart Here – Enter Your Zip Code
Can You Install A New Roof On Top Of Old Shingles
Many homeowners wonder whether or not its a good idea to install a roof on top of existing shingles .
The biggest reason for keeping the existing layer of old roofing is obvious extra cost. As we just explained above many people would rather avoid spending an additional $1,000 on removing the old shingles.
Despite the high cost, doing this is absolutely essential! Leaving the old material will greatly accelerate the disintegration of the new roof and shorten its life cycle.
This is because ventilation is reduced, which in turn increases the average temperature of the shingles, causing the product to dry up quicker and the granules to start falling off faster.
Another reason why you should NOT leave the old shingles is because a roofer will typically not install underlayment between old and new roofing.
If there are pre-existing problems in the leak prone areas: such as skylights, chimneys, vents and valleys, installing new shingles will not solve them! This means that your new roof will continue to leak.
Failing to tear off old roofing will also negatively impact your warranty. Most large shingle manufacturers explicitly state that your material and labor warranty automatically becomes void, if their product was installed on top of an old roof.
In most states, the building codes require that you remove the old roofing materials, if there are more than two layers of it already there.
Don’t Miss: What Rash Looks Like Shingles
Should You Consider Diy Shingles Installation
As we discussed before, professional labor to install a new asphalt shingles roof constitutes at least 70% of the total cost. This means that you can potentially save thousands of dollars if you can do the tear off and installation yourself.
The million dollar questions is, should you?
When it comes to asphalt shingles, one of their biggest benefits is that they are extremely DIY friendly. Indeed, asphalt shingles is one of the very few roofing materials that a handy homeowner can put up on their own.
Shingle installation does not require any special tools or technical training. This is the reason why so many roofers install them its the easiest entry point in this field.
You can purchase all the necessary materials and supplies at your local big box home improvement store, and avoid the hassle of hiring a roofing company. In fact, basic 3-tab roofing shingles is one of the cheapest roofing options out there, and you can have a brand new roof for under $3,000.
Moreover, there are many step-by-step guides and YouTube videos on how do this correctly.
Keep in mind that when you buy shingles, you need to carefully measure your roof and also buy extra shingles to account for the waste factor. Typically, gable roofs require about 5% waste, while hip roofs are about 7.5%
Still, if you do everything carefully and educate yourself about the nuances of proper installation, you can do a very successful shingle install and keep thousands of dollars in your pocket.
Regional Roofing Shingles Cost Differences
When you research shingle prices online and compare them to quotes from your local contractors you may discover a surprising fact: these prices can be VERY DIFFERENT.
This is not because online information is false, or roofers are out of touch with reality. Rather, actual roof installation costs vary widely, depending on where you live.
Different costs of living, from very high to very low, basically set the standard for labor rates in a particular region.
If you live in an expensive city, such as New York or San Francisco, you will be paying a premium price for a new install.
This premium can be as high as 18% more than the national average. On the opposite end, if you live in a small town somewhere in the middle of Arkansas, you will be paying less than the national averages sited online. Often, as much as 16% less.
Read Also: How To Recover Quickly From Shingles
How Much Do Architectural Shingles Cost
The average cost for an architectural shingle roof will range between $13,500 to $21,500 depending on the slope, pitch, and size of your roof. You can expect to pay $1.00 to $1.50 per sq. foot or $100 to $150per square installed on a standard sized single story home. 50 year architectural roofing shingles could cost from $500 to $785 per square .
Roof replacement costs can vary by region, but it is always smart to get a few price estimates before contacting a local roofing installer.
Roof Installation Cost Calculator
Cost To Remove Old Roofing
Before your roofer can install new shingles, he needs to remove the old roof. Removal and tear off fees can be expensive.
It costs as much as $55 per square to take down one layer of old shingles, and $84 per square to tear off two layers. So if you need to remove 2,000 sq.ft. of old materials you will be spending $1,000 1,680, depending on the number of layers.
You May Like: What Does Early Stages Of Shingles Look Like
How To Calculate Shingle Costs For Your Roofing Project
To calculate how much roofing material you need, youll need to know the square footage of your roof, along with its pitch.
Square footage is measured by taking the length and width of each plane on the roof, and multiplying those numbers. A roofs pitch is determined by how measuring how much your roof rises for every foot it runs. For example, a 6 in 12 roof pitch means the roof rises 6 inches for every 12 horizontal inches of length.
Once you have these numbers, use an online Roof Shingles Calculator to for an accurate estimate. Youll also want to add about 10% to 15% in additional materials to account for waste.
Cost Of Architectural Vs 3
Across the board, you will notice that laminated or architectural shingles cost about 20-35% more than standard 3-tab shingles.
To a naked eye, this cost difference can be attributed to curb appeal: laminated shingles provide a more dimensional, attractive appearance.
However, the real reason for the extra cost is material composition, and as a result longevity and durability of the shingles.
One of the biggest differences between these three different classes of shingles is the thickness on the product. Architectural shingles have a body that is about 30% thicker compared to 3-tabs, and designer shingles can be as much as 50% thicker.
Thicker shingles are more durable, long lasting, as well as weather resistant. Another huge benefit is that these shingles look a lot more attractive and dimensional than 3-tabs, which have a very flat appearance.
Don’t Miss: Are Shingles Contagious To Others
Architectural Vs 3 Tab Shingles
These two types of shingles are both made from asphalt but have very different appearances. 3 tab shingles are flat and have a single tab shape and size. Architectural shingles, on the other hand, are referred to as dimensional shingles because they provide a more dimensional look to the roof.
Architectural shingles are also considered to have a longer lifespan than 3 tab shingles. This is because architectural shingles are more resistant to extreme weather conditions. On average, architectural shingles last for up to 30 years and 3 tab shingles last about 7 to 10 years in bad weather conditions and 12 to 15 in good weather conditions.
Choosing The Right Shingles
Lowes provides homeowners with solid 3-tab and architectural roofing shingle options.
Owens Corning architectural roofing shingles are the costliest at Lowes, but theyre also one of the most durable entries on this list. The Owens Cornings 3-tab Supreme line, on the other hand, is the least expensive, featuring shingles that are thinner than their architectural counterparts.
Whichever solution you choose, go for Lowes roofing shingles that match your homes demands and aesthetic.
Buying architectural models is a high-return investment that pays off in the long run.
Recommended Reading: Is There A Booster For Shingles Vaccine
Replace Shingles Vs New Roof
A new roof costs an average of $8,500, while repairs typically average around $550. The cost of roof replacement can vary depending on your materials, however, as some shingles cost more to repair than others. Slate roof repairs average a cost of $700 to $2,500, while asphalt shingle repair averages $300 to $1,000. If your roof material is more expensive, it may be more cost effective to put on a new roof with new materials vs. simply repairing the existing shingles.
The Best Roofing Shingle Brands At Lowes
If you think asphalt roofing shingles at Lowes are the best option for your project, you should know what the manufacturers have to offer.
They feature products from several companies that provide top-grade architectural and three-tab solutions that may suit your needs.
|Owens Corning Oakridge Roof Shingles|
|Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration Shingles|
|Owens Corning Supreme 3-Tab Shingles|
|GAF Royal Sovereign 3-Tab Shingles|
Recommended Reading: Elk Corp Of Texas Shingles