Gaf Vs Certainteed Which Is The Best Roofing Shingles
Before you begin: Want to know more about GAF and CertainTeed? Check out our individual reviews for each company.
In the roofing shingle industry, no two names are more known than GAF and CertainTeed. This review compares GAF vs. CertainTeed side by side and declares a winner between CertainTeed vs. GAF for the best roofing shingle.
Energy Efficiency: Cool Roof Shingles
This is a growing sector of the market, driven by consumer demand for building materials that help reduce energy use. The asphalt shingle industry is striving to stay relevant to homeowners looking for green roofing options. The goal is to prevent further market share loss to metal roofing, primarily, but also to clay/concrete tiles, composite shingles, and other innovative products.
Reflectivity: To do this, brands like Owens Corning and GAF are producing energy efficient shingles. The key to an energy-reducing shingle is reflectivity reflecting the suns radiant heat away from the roof rather than absorbing it into the attic where some of the heat will penetrate the house and cause the air conditioning to work extra hard at an extra cost.
The goal is energy efficiency recognized by independent testing agencies including these prominent groups: The Department of Energys Energy Star program, the worldwide Cool Roof Rating Council, and the local but influential California Title 24. See more on Title 24 below.
Here are the energy efficient shingles from the two brands:
Is Tamko Better Than Certainteed
Quality And Performance. A study published by Consumer Reports in June 2009 shows that CertainTeed branded shingles are better than their Tamko counterparts. Both products have similar scores when it came to strength, resilience, and weather resistance. CertainTeed products were better though at resisting impact damage
Also Check: How Do You Get Rid Of Shingles Pain
Return On Investment Is This A Reason To Replace Your Roof
In dollars, if you spend $20,000 on shingles, the investment will increase your homes value by $12,000 to $13,600. In short, you will lose money if you sell immediately.
Roof replacement is not cost effective for home sellers unless the old roof is in horrible condition and will thus discourage buyers maxing out their budget, with little room or optionality for a new roof or those who dont want the hassle.
Pro Tip: Value drops as the upfront cost goes up. Our recommendation for maximum ROI is to buy a popular mid-price shingle like OC Duration or Duration Designer or Landmark/Landmark Premium rather than high-end shingles. Installed costs for these shingles average about $450-$650 per square , depending on your homes location, roof complexity, and project specific variables.
Sure, the OC Berkshire and CertainTeed Presidential Shake options have tremendous curb appeal but spending $600-$850 per square on roofing is hard to recoup.
Gaf Timberline Shingles Vs Owens Corning
These are the most popular shingles from either brand and this division includes the very important GAF Timberline vs. Owens Corning Duration shingle comparison. Timberline and Duration are two of the top-selling shingle lines from any brand.
GAF: To stay consistent, we begin with GAF architectural shingles, and the list is based on the cost, starting with the most affordable GAF architectural shingles. The products in this section are all GAF Timberline shingles. One of the Timberline shingle series is Cool Series EPAs Energy Star rated shingles. Cool Roof shingles are covered in greater detail within the Energy Efficient Shingles section below.
Each series comes with a Lifetime Limited Warranty against manufacturer defects plus the GAF StainGuard algae stain protection warranty. Most wind warranties are 130 MPH the HDZ and AH shingles have an Unlimited wind warranty when you install a complete GAF roof system complete with starter strip shingles, ridge cap shingles, roof deck protection and either attic ventilation or leak barrier such as .
Timberline Natural Shadow : If youre looking for a low-cost architectural shingle aka dimensional shingle, this is it. At about the cost of the GAF Royal Sovereign 3-tab shingles, it includes a prorated lifetime warranty. The Timberline NS shingles are designed to look like wood shakes.
$8,225See Roof Costs in Your Area
Don’t Miss: How Contagious Is Shingles Virus
Which Is A Better Shingle: Certainteed Or Gaf
In most cases, homeowners cant go wrong with either CertainTeed or GAF shingles. However, each brand has its own advantages, so CertainTeed would be better suited for certain homeowners while GAF would work better for others. The main difference between CertainTeed and GAF shingles is that CertainTeed offers premium shingles for a higher price while GAF tends to be more budget-friendly.
Oc Vs Gaf Energy Efficiency
As more and more homeowners are leaning towards finding more sustainable, green options for their homes, shingle manufacturers have had to innovate. Both brands have taken steps to improve energy efficiency with their shingles in different ways.
GAF has crafted their Timberline Cool Series shingles to reflect heat without having to be light in color. In the past, only white roofs would have such reflective capacity, but their specially designed granules were designed to reflect more light which reduces the transfer of heat to the space below, thus preventing the home from heating up from the sun. They come in medium to dark hues, and having a dark roof with the same, if not more, reflectivity as other cooling shingles is an incredible benefit.
On the other hand, Owens Corning has their Cool Roof Collection featuring two asphalt shingles produced to deflect heat from your home: The TruDefinition Duration Cool and the OC TruDefinition Premium Cool Shingles. Every shingle in the Cool Roof Collection features innovative solar-reflecting granules to comply with the Solar Reflectance Index requirements.
When it comes to energy efficiency, these brands are in even tow. So it really comes down to style preference and cost. For the most affordable options, homeowners could choose either the Timberline HDZ Reflector Series or Owens Corning Duration Cool.
Contact Your Local Owens Corning Certified Contractor
You May Like: What Do Shingles Look Like When They Start
Owens Corning Shingles Durability And Lifespan
Owens Corning offers a range of products, from 3-tab to traditional architectural shingles to premium Class 4.
The entry 3-tab shingles are designed with a 25-year rating, while the Class 4 shingles have the most durability and most extended lifespan at 50 years. Most asphalt shingles, regardless of brand, dont last to manufacturer specs, like most cars dont achieve the gas mileage per gallon listed on a window sticker. One would need to drive a vehicle precisely as tested for the mileage average to be realized. Similarly, homeowners in areas of high moisture, extreme sun or wind, and hail-prone regions will likely need to replace their roofs sooner than in otherwise optimal conditions.
Lets look at the most popular Owens Corning shingle, the Duration product. So, how long do Owens Corning Duration shingles last?
For example, if you live in Colorado, with extreme sun, wind, and frequent hail, you can expect these 30-year rated shingles to be less than 30 years. Your roof must be installed correctly and have good ventilation and insulation to last this long. Owens Corning boasts its Total Protection Roofing System, where roofing, ventilation, and insulation work together to protect your home and roof.
Regular roof inspections and maintenance are things you can do to extend your Owens Corning Duration shingles lifespan.
Owens Corning Shingles Wind Resistance
Owens Corning Shingles Fire Resistance
Owens Corning Shingles Algae Resistance
What Makes Owens Corning Duration And Gaf Timberline Shingles So Popular
Weâve already covered that Owens Corning and GAF are top shingle brands. Weâll now discuss each brandâs respective top-selling products, namely the Owens Corning Duration shingles and the GAF Timberline shingles.
We will focus on the Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration shingle vs. the GAF Timberline HDZ shingle.
|Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration
|SureNail technology nailing area
|StrikeZone nailing area
Both are architectural shingles, compared to 3-tab shingles or luxury shingles. Both brands are frequently selected by home builders, roofing contractors, and homeowners who want a cost-effective architectural shingle.
Both are top products with Class A fire rating, the industryâs top fire-resistance rating. A Class A fire rating means the shingles can withstand a direct flame for sustained periods without igniting.
Both have wind resistance ratings at 130 miles per hour . Based on standard wind resistance testing, these shingles rate between the top two classes, G and H. Class G can withstand winds up to 120 MPH while Class H can withstand winds up to 150 MPH.
Most roofing companies across the US will be pleased to install either brand when deciding between GAF vs. Owens Corning shingles, so there is no clear winner on which is better.
Recommended Reading: Does Health Insurance Cover Shingles Vaccine
Owens Corning Shingle Roofing Price
Owens Corning shingles prices range between $100 to $204 per square. This range is wide but includes entry 3-tab and luxury shingles. In roofing, 100 square feet equals 1 Square.
Styles and individual Owens Corning products will have different life expectancies, wind ratings, impact resistance ratings, thicknesses, and color options. Some will require additional roofing materials to install to manufacturer installation guidelines. For example, the Owens Corning Duration shingles price averages $120 per square and is a 30-year rated shingle, with a 130 mile per hour wind resistance rating.
We recommend contacting a reputable, local roofing company to get the most accurate Owens Corning shingle prices. Of course, one can purchase Owens Corning materials directly at a home improvement retailer based on which products and colors are available or inquire directly to a large roofing supply distributor.
Gaf Vs Certainteed Warranty
A brands warranty is a sign of the companys quality and the confidence they have in their product. When comparing CertainTeed and GAF, you see that both brands have multiple types of warranties.
However, both brands also have plenty of loopholes that can make it difficult and frustrating to get a claim approved. Common issues that will void a claim include improper installation , airborne chemicals, shingles installed in cold weather, or poor ventilation of attics and roof decks.
Given that GAF has more stringent warranties, there are more reasons for claim denials than CertainTeed. To have the best success at having a claim approved, be picky about choosing an experienced roofer that follows the manufacturers guidelines.
Pro tip: To ensure you get the most protection, choose a contractor that also offers an installation warranty, which will cover any repairs or problems caused by installer error.
Read Also: Name Of The Shingles Vaccine
Certainteed Vs Owens Corning: Who Makes A Superior Asphalt Shingle
Finding the right roof shingles for your home maybe even more important than you think.
Not only will you have to look at them every day, but they also have a huge impact on the longevity of your home. To help you find the perfect shingle, were going to break down two of the most popular asphalt shingle brands on the market CertainTeed vs. Owens Corning.
Like weve done in a previous test, well break them down by weight, nail zone, pull test, coverage, count per bundle, online reputation, granule loss, contractors programs, sealant test, and warranty issues.
Follow along for a side-by-side comparison as we find out who makes a Superior Asphalt Shingle in 2022.
Every Roofing Job Is Different
Of course, each contractor has a different way of pricing projects. Therefore, the contractor that you choose will also affect the cost of your project.
On average, a new roof can range anywhere from $6,000 to $17,000. A metal roof may cost between $5,000 to $27,000. Meanwhile, the most popular roofing material asphalt shingles may cost $4,000 to $6,200 for a full installation.
Then, there are high-end roofing installations. A tile roof may cause from $20,500 to $34,000 to install. Meanwhile, a slate roof may cost about $12,300 to $21,000 for a full roof installation.
You May Like: When Should You Start Getting The Shingles Vaccine
Warranties Overview: Which Brand Has Better Warranties
This chart provides an overview of GAF vs. Owens Corning warranties:
The three main areas in which asphalt shingle warranties protect you are for material defects, , wind damage, and staining mainly caused by algae.
Note that no warranty covers Hail Impact Damage, even if the shingles have class 4 hail rating. You can still obtain a discount on homeowners insurance premiums with the class 4 Hail rated shingles, but there is no warranty against hail from any asphalt shingle manufacturer.
Roof Coverage Per Bundle
The common rule of thumb with shingle coverage is that three bundles equate to cover one square of the area of a roof. Both CertainTeed and Owens Corning came up just short here, each scoring 4s. Nothing to be too worried about, but its good to know what you can expect in the coverage department when purchasing your singles.
Recommended Reading: How Long Does Shingles Pain Last After Rash
Basic Three Tab Strip Or 3
Every manufacturer makes 3-tab shingles. Also called strip shingles, they are a single layer of fiberglass mat immersed in an asphalt mix. The lower half of the shingle is cut to resemble either three wood shakes or slate tiles. The tabs are covered in roofing granules typically made with ceramic to shed rainwater and reflect radiant sunlight.
The major advantage of 3-tab shingle is cost. These are the most affordable asphalt shingles with a starting retail price of about $75 per square , and an installed cost starting at about $300 to $350 per square . Strip shingles have a very traditional appearance because they were the only shingle type for nearly 100 years. These are fine shingles for areas that dont experience strong winds.
The disadvantages start with the degree of roofing protection 3-tab shingles are thinner and lighter, so they do not protect as well against hail and wind. They are fine for rain, even torrential rain.
The 3-tab shingle limitations cause shorter manufacturer warranties. And wind warranties are 60 MPH or 80 MPH rather than the industry standard of of 110 MPH 130 MPH for most architectural shingles.
Aesthetically, 3 tab shingles dont have the deeper shadowing that real wood and stone roofing offer the kind of shadowing that is better imitated by dimensional/architectural shingles.
GAF 3-Tab Shingles vs. Owens Corning
With GAF, you have two options, and thats an immediate advantage for GAF over the single 3-tab line from Owens Corning.
Is Certainteed Landmark A 30
Yes, CertainTeed Landmark shingles are designed to last for about 30 years if theyre installed and maintained correctly over time. Although these shingles can be more expensive than other shingle types and brands, many homeowners believe its worth it because they have a longer lifespan. Most other asphalt shingle types are expected to last about 15-25 years.
Recommended Reading: What Does The Medical Condition Shingles Look Like
The Verdict: Which Is Best
To find out which shingle is the best, we simply averaged the scores they got for each category. Owens Corning came out with a 4.6, which is a really good score. Meanwhile, CertainTeed scored a 4.2, which is still very respectable.
So, while Owens Corning does have a fairly big edge when compared to CertainTeed, both are very viable options.
To help you more with your decision, here are some other factors to consider when choosing your shingles.
Gaf Timberline Cool Series
Thanks to modern reflective technology, you can join the green revolution with products like GAF’s Timberline® Cool Series. The shingles use specially-designed roofing granules that have greater reflectance than traditional shingles. The resultless heat to the space below to keep you cooler in the summer. Timberline® Cool Series shingles are also made with the patented StainGuard® algae protection to assure the beauty of your roof against unsightly blue-green algae.
You May Like: Is Apple Cider Vinegar Good For Shingles
Top 10 Best Brands Of Roofing Shingles
You can narrow your roofing material search down with a few tips about the best roof shingles on the market. Consumer Reports conducts reviews of various products, including the best roofing shingles brands.
Its been ten years since the consumer group reported on roofing materials. The company assessed asphalt roofing shingles because its currently the most popular choice in the nation.
The report reveals that its easy to distinguish the thicknesses of various roofing brands. The report states that some brands shingles are so thick that you can easily see theyre three times more durable than other brands.
Longevity is the most important feature of a roofing shingle. Resultantly, Consumer Reports conducted a test that replicated the load and conditions asphalt shingles endure over time.
The consumer group focused on the weak spots in shingles because thats where they typically incur damage. The magazine used various devices to simulate intense hail to tell which ones will bend, crack or dent. They also conducted a test to see which shingles will stand up to the ultraviolet rays of the sun.
The report reveals that standard single-layer asphalt shingles can only stand up to around 60 mile-per-hour winds and moderate hail and debris impacts. Multilayered asphalt shingles, however, can withstand winds of 110 mph.
What Class Are Certainteed Landmark Shingles
In terms of impact resistance, CertainTeed boasts a Class 4 rating, which is the highest possible rating. This heavyweight brands shingles typically contain more asphalt than most others. This helps keep shingles in place during strong storms and high winds. All of its lines also use granules with algae-fighting copper.
In terms of fire rating, most lines of CertainTeed shingles have a Class A fire rating, which is the top rating for asphalt roofing. The brand also recently introduced FireHalt dimensional shingles and FireScreen 3-tab, which offers enhanced protection from fire.
Read Also: Does L Lysine Help With Shingles